The lowdown: 'He Knew He Was Right' is a four-part BBC drama based on the 1869 novel by Anthony
Trollope, and first broadcast on 18 April 2004. The series begins with the marriage of Louis Trevelyan
(Oliver Dimsdale) and Emily Rowley (Laura Fraser). Several years pass and the seemingly happy couple
have a son, but Louis becomes suspicious and more than a bit jealous when Emily begins spending a lot
of time with Colonel Osborne (Bill Nighy), an old friend of her father. She assures Louis that the friendship
is completely innocent, but he forbids her to see the Colonel. Emily is very stubborn and refuses to bow 
to his command, and her continued friendship with Osborne eventually sees herself and her son banished
from the family home.

There are also a number of subplots involving other characters, and again love is the common theme. One
of these plots involves the local clergyman, Mr Gibson (superbly played by David Tennant), who has a keen
eye for the ladies. He first courts Dorothy Stanbury, the niece of a wealthy spinster, and then two sisters,
Arabella and Camilla French. Gibson rather hastily proposes to Camila, a very domineering young woman, 
but soon regrets his rash action and calls off the wedding. He then proposes to Arabella, who has a much
more friendly disposition. Tennant is at his best in the scenes where he reveals to Camila that he cannot
marry her. Meanwhile, Louis sets about to gain custody of his son, and flees with the child to Italy, vowing 
to never return to England. However, Emily tracks him down and finds him close to death, and with the
couple reunited, he dies in her arns. The series ends with Gibson seemingly happily married to Arabella.

The verdict: As one would expect from a BBC historical drama, it has superb production values. A very
striking feature of the series is the way most of the main characters regularly speak directly to camera, 
which helps draw the viewer in to the plot and is quite effective. Many of the actors will be very familiar:
Laura Fraser appeared with David Tennant in 'Casanova', and Geoffrey Palmer from the 2007 'Doctor Who'
Christmas Special, plays Emily's father. Other actors include Anna-Louise Plowman (Dalek), Philip Madoc
(The Brain of Morbius) and Ron Cook (The Idiot's Lantern). If you enjoy historical dramas, this one is very
highly recommended. Bravo to the Beeb for continuing to invest in quality drama rather than simply making
more reality shows.



 DVD
 
Novel

           << Back to the David Tennant page